Quality Assurance/Quality Control: An Integral Part of Brownfields Redevelopment

When a community wins a brownfields redevelopment grant from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the recipient organization must agree to meet specific quality assurance requirements. Even if the community receives no funding from EPA, quality assurance is still a worthwhile procedure to follow in attaining high-caliber results in a brownfields redevelopment project.

Quality assurance (QA) is a set of management activites that helps to ensure success in any organized business endeavor. Quality control (QC) is the measuring tool (or tools) used to test a business process against known standards.

Communities begin the QA/QC process by defining their problem and determining what information they need to solve it. This activity is known as setting data quality objectives (DQO) as shown in the seven-step process in Figure 1.

If a community uses EPA resources to collect environmental data at the brownfields site, then municipal officials must establish a QA/QC system, including a quality management plan for documentation purposes.

Communities must also compile a quality assurance project plan that lays out the specific quality objectives for brownfields site assessment activities.

Meeting EPA quality requirements can be a challenging process to communities without QA/QC experience. Outreach specialists with the TOSC and TAB programs can provide assistance in understanding how to meet these requirements. A factsheet on QA/QC is available at: www.hsrc.org/hsrc/html/tosc/sswtosc/update15.pdf.

At EPA, the following individuals and web sites may be helpful in providing information regarding quality requirements at brownfields sites:

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response (OSWER)
Greg Jordon 
Telephone: 202-566-2751

EPA Region 6
Don Johnson, QA Manager
Telephone: 214-665-8343

EPA Region 4
Gary Bennett, QA Contact
Telephone: 706-355-8500

EPA also provides assistance that can be read on the web or downloaded. The topics and web addresses are as follows:

The primary South & Southwest HSRC contact for information on QA/QC programs is Faith Stephens at fstephens@hsrc.lsu.edu.



Environmental Factsheets Valuable Community Resource

Over the past three years, the Hazardous Substance Research Centers' outreach program has prepared a library of factsheets to help communities understand common environmental hazards. Factsheets are now available on 15 topics, but the series is continuing to add titles and is available to read or download on the web. Just go to www.hsrc-ssw.org and select the "Technical Outreach" button. On the page that comes up on your computer screen, choose "Publications." Titles in the factsheet series include:

  • Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) in Brownfields Redevelopment Projects March 2004
  • Understanding the Principles of Groundwater December 2003
  • Guidelines for Getting a Contaminated Site Placed on the National Priorities List June 2003
  • Environmental Update of the Petroleum Industry June 2003
  • A Community Guide to Safe Landfill Management September 2002
  • Understanding the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) June 2002
  • Understanding the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA) April 2002
  • Understanding the Potential Environmental Hazards of Asbestos March 2002
  • Understanding EPA's Underground Storage Tank Regulations February 2002
  • Introducing the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) January 2002
  • Understanding the Hazards of Arsenic in Drinking Water November 2001
  • Environmental Overview of the Concrete and Cement Industries August 2001
  • The Environmental Impact of Dry Cleaning Operations April-May 2001
  • Petroleum Contaminants in Groundwater March 2001
  • Understanding the Potential Hazards of MTBE February 2001

Send suggested topics for future Environmental Update factsheets to Mark Hodges at 404/894-6987 or mark.hodges@gtri.gatech.edu.



TOSC Developing Method for Determining Accidental Toxic Releases

Environmental permitting requirements restrict the amount of toxic chemicals that manufacturing plants are allowed to release. These regulations were designed to keep industries from dumping excessive pollutants into the environment, but they do not take into account accidental releases, which may account for a significant source of a company's total contamination.

How great a problem do accidental releases pose? The answers are likely to vary from place to place, but grassroots organizations often have trouble making realistic assessments because of the voluminous regulatory paperwork that they must analyze.

TOSC staff members at LSU are trying to develop a method for communities to generate such estimates, and they are using Louisiana's Calcasieu Parish as a case study.

Calcasieu Parish has been home to a number of oil refineries and other petrochemical industrial facilities in Louisiana since the 1930s and 1940s. Consequently, the parish is responsible for a large amount of the state's toxic releases to air, soil and water. The Calcasieu Estuary contains high levels of toxic substances, including PAHs, PCBs, and metals such as mercury, zinc, lead, and copper.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) carried out a remedial investigation in Calcasieu Parish, releasing its report in 2003 that declared the area a "Superfund initiative." TOSC became involved in the investigation when the Calcasieu League for Environmental Action Now (CLEAN) asked its staff to review EPA's report on the group's behalf and assist them in interpreting the findings. CLEAN also requested that TOSC focus in particular on the accidental releases of contaminants into the air by existing Calcasieu industries.

In the study that has ensued, TOSC outreach specialists Denise Rousseau Ford and Tomeka Prioleau have built off the work of Wilma Subra, a Louisiana-based chemist, community activist, and member of the TOSC advisory committee. Subra used Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) data to provide information on the levels of accident or unauthorized releases of toxic chemicals into the air by Louisiana industrial facilities.

In Louisiana, one of the complicating factors in assessing accidental releases is that companies make two different reports to the Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ). The initial estimate is submitted within two days of the incident as a kind of best guess of the scope of a release. Companies send more refined assessments to DEQ within a week of the incident, and the agency places these latter totals in quarterly and annual reports.

TOSC's study is focusing on accidental releases by 21 companies in Calcasieu Parish. Ford and Prioleau are looking through DEQ reports to identify unusual or irregular emissions and compile information on the frequency and amount of toxic chemical releases. They are interested in the impact of accidental releases to Calcasieu's total contamination picture, but they also want to identify a method for efficiently finding this information.

Prioleau says that communities often fail to get the answers they need because they don't know the right questions to ask or who to ask for the information. "We're doing a lot of research at the Department of Environmental Quality, trying to establish a procedure for communities to follow," she says.

Ford believes that greater knowledge of the scope accidental releases will be in invaluable for communities in their negotiations with companies over realistic cleanup operations. "This is strong information to come to the table with," she says.

The study began in August 2003 and should be completed by August 2004. For more information, contact Ford or Prioleau at 225-578-6770 or by e-mail at: drf@hsrc.lsu.edu.




TAB Program Receives Contract Extension

The South & Southwest HSRC Technical Assistance to Brownfield Communities Program (TAB) was awarded a three-year extension of its existing contract with the U.S. EPA Brownfields Office beginning in 2004.

Delays in disbursement of grant funds to the South and Southwest HSRC, however, has caused a temporary suspension of TAB activities in Region IV due to a lack of funds to assist its eight TAB client communities.

Nevertheless, TAB staff members continue to remain in contact with their communities and municipalities. When funding is resumed, TAB technical assistance efforts will immediately restart.

Click here to download a document summarizing TAB's assistance to its eight current communities to date.




TOSC Assists 10 Communities in First Quarter 2004

In the first quarter of 2004, the Technical Outreach Services to Communities (TOSC) program assisted 10 communities in EPA's Regions IV and VI. The communities included several communities new to the program. Several other communities were inactive in the first quarter but are expected to become active as cleanup work progresses in these areas. In addition, TOSC is continuing to pursue new communities, and several are expected to become active in the second quarter.

In other program activities, TOSC contacted several Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) in Region VI to strengthen ties and form collaborative relationships. Program staff members also met with Dr. George DaBai of Langston University in Oklahoma in April and the outreach team attended the National Environmental Justice Advisory Council Meeting in New Orleans, Louisiana, in April. The latter meeting focused on the council's document on cumulative risks and impacts entitled "Ensuring Risk Reduction in Communities with Multiple Stressors: Environmental Justice and Cumulative Risks/Impacts."

The TOSC team presented a session on "TOSC & TAB Assistance: What's Our Legal Liability" during the TOSC/TAB/EPA National Conference in St. Louis, March 31.

Click here to download a summary document describing TOSC assistance to communities in the first quarter.




Web Resources for Community Cleanup and Redevelopment

The World Wide Web has a wealth of information for communities involved in environmental cleanup or redevelopment projects. Here is a sampling of resources:

  • In 1997, GSA launched the Brownfields Redevelopment Initiative to identify and redeploy underutilized federal properties. Read about some of the success stories of this program at: http://bri.gsa.gov/brownfields/success/

  • Brownfields-oriented conferences at the Center for Brownfields Initiatives site: www.brownfields.com/conferences.htm

  • Toolkit developed by EPA on how to set up a community advisory group to participate in decision-making for Superfund projects or other sites with environmental problems. www.epa.gov/superfund/tools/cag/cagtlktc.pdf

  • EnviroTools is a site at Michigan State University established to empower citizen participation in cleaning up contaminated sites. It has a page with links to fact sheets on topics such as: 1) community building; 2) environmental assessment; 3) pollutants, fate, transport and behavior; 4) health effects on humans and the environment; 5) risk assessment; 6) regulations and legal considerations; 7) finances; 8) remediation; and 9) redevelopment. To access these resources, go to: www.egr.msu.edu/~envirotools/cgi-bin/factsheets.php3.

  • EPA funding will support training for over 1,000 persons for environmental jobs in brownfields communities nationwide. In its ongoing efforts to promote economic revitalization and safeguard the environment and public health, EPA has announced the awarding of its second round of Brownfields Job Training Grants under the new Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act of 2002. www.epa.gov/brownfields/archive/pilot_arch.htm

  • Go to the EPA Brownfields Technology Support Center to download a 21-page document entitled, Improving Decision Quality: Making the Case for Adopting Next Generation Site Characterization Practices. www.brownfieldstsc.org/publications_index.htm

  • Small Community Quarterly is a new, free electronic newsletter published by the National Center for Small Communities (NCSC). The NCSC provides small-town decisionmakers with tools to govern effectively and skills to expand local economies, protect natural resources and preserve community character. Go to: www.natat.org/ncsc/ and select "Publications." The newsletter is on the publications link page.

  • The Sustainable Communities Network offers a downloadable brochure with ideas for how communities can plan a sustainable event as well as a starter kit for a community member, city official, planner, or design professional to identify available planning tools and assess their appropriateness. www.sustainable.org/

  • The Florida Brownfields Association (FBA) is posting a "Call for Posters" for the 2004 Florida Brownfields Conference held in Sarasota, Florida, August 15-18. Proposals 250 words or less are due June 15 and should be sent to: Shawna Chandler, FBA Board Member, 7856 Westside Park Drive, Suite G, Mobile, AL 36695, (251)776-7344, Fax: (251)776-1758, schandler@aerostar.net. For more information, go to pdf/fla-brownfields.pdf.

  • The national Brownfields 2004 conference will be held September 20-22 in St. Louis, Missouri. For more details, go to: http://www.brownfields2004.org/

If you have any resources to publish in this newsletter, please send them to mark.hodges@gtri.gatech.edu.
Please feel free to forward this newsletter on to your friends, family and colleagues.

To contact us for any more information, please see below.

Clean Communities E-Newsletter

Mark Hodges, Editor
GTRI/EOEML
Georgia Tech
Atlanta, GA  30332-0837
Email: mark.hodges@gtri.gatech.edu
Phone: 404.894.6987
Fax: 404.894.8184

All content is (C) Copyright 2004.